Call me crazy, but I am a dyed flaming redheaded conservative, alternative rock-loving, tattooed, Sinead O'Connor fan who knows every song from the '50's and '60's, and card carrying member of the Republican party.
A rant....
Published on December 19, 2004 By iamheather In Life Journals

I must purge myself of a mother's overprotective outrage. It is probably stupid and meaningless, but the feeling remains; so I blog.

We live in a nice family oriented suburb of Houston, complete with two car garages, beautifully green lawns peppered with pine trees that stretch to the sky. Our children take full advantage of the outdoors. We have a fort and swing set in the back yard. We live on a cul-de-sac, so traffic is of little concern while they ride their bikes. Our house is the gathering place for all the neighborhood kids to play. On any given day, the sounds of children echo from the back yard, front yard, and through the halls of our home as they run in and out for bathroom and drink breaks.

My oldest son, Joshua, has severe ADHD and highly functioning autism. This means he talks rather loudly, off topic, and very animatedly. We are just glad he talks with other children at this point. He used to be a recluse. He was self-conscious and disliked all forms of social activity. He also hated to be outdoors because the sights, sounds, smells, and feel of things outside overloaded his senses. He becomes over stimulated quickly. Last year, he would never touch grass, dirt, ride his bike, or play on a swing. He has improved by leaps and bounds this past year through behavior therapy and medication. Watching him relate to peers, dive in the grass, and express enthusiasm is the greatest blessing to my heart.

Our backyard shares a fence with posh townhouses that line the streets behind our home. Most of these townhouses are occupied by retirees with money or yuppie collegiates. The commonality between them being their lack of children and affinity for quiet.

My children only play outside until dinner time. By 6:00 pm, good-byes have been said, toys picked up, and washing commenced. The only sounds outside by this time are created by the squirrels jumping on roofs, possums climbing through bushes, and our townhouse neighbor's large barking dog.

Yesterday, the retired lady who lives behind us paid a friendly visit. (We will hence forth refer to her as Ann, annoying neighbor nuisance.) Ann rang our doorbell at 6:30 pm, well after outdoor play time, to introduce us to her visiting grandchildren. She wanted to know if they could join in the playing and raucous at our house tomorrow, as there are no other children on their retired, yuppie street. Of course, my children were delighted to have more friends join in the games. While she was here, Joshua expressed his delight in his usually animated and boisterous style.

"Oh, so you are the child that is so loud," Ann declared to Joshua. "You don't know how to talk quietly, do you?"

"I am the 8 year old! (bubbly laughter) I am in second grade and the oldest, the big brother," he rambunctiously responded.

"Well, my husband was trying to sleep the other day and the college girl upstairs was sick, and you kept them awake. You are just too loud," Ann ridiculed.

"I am sorry about that. Joshua is quite loud at times when he is enjoying himself. After all, most children are. If he bothers your husband again, feel free to let me know, and I will address my son," I said, while biting my tongue through a patronizing smile.

Ann's grandchildren did not come over to play today. My son, Jakob, cried because he thought they didn't like him. Joshua worried that something bad had happened to them. Rachel was confused when she saw them through the window while she was perched in the fort.

Am I just an overprotective mother? Was it incredibly rude of Ann to address my son in that way? Could she not have had a private conversation with me about Joshua? Aren't children playing outside allowed to run, scream, yell, and be, well, children? Was her whole visit a pretense to discipline my son? Would she be more understanding if I explained Joshua's situation? Can her husband buy some sort of "white noise" device to drown out the sounds of children at play? Is Ann just too uptight and grouchy?

 

 

 

 

 


Comments (Page 1)
2 Pages1 2 
on Dec 19, 2004
I'll go with rude and grouchy. I probably would have had a word with her after she said what she did. I wouldn't have been able to hold back. Good on you for restraining yourself. I hope Ann doesn't turn into one of those neighbours from hell, though.
on Dec 19, 2004

Dynamaso, I wanted so badly to protect my baby. I know that sounds awful, but I just couldn't help it. The lioness in me was awakened! I know she doesn't understand Joshua's situation, but my heart hurt for him. I was afraid all his progress would be crushed. I know Joshua is stronger than that, but still. Ugh...I just had to express in the blog what I restrained.

Good on you for restraining yourself. I hope Ann doesn't turn into one of those neighbours from hell, though.

Thank you, and me too.

 

on Dec 19, 2004
Yippee, acronyms for neighbors. I thought Joshua's response to her was rather good And I have to wonder, are your houses so close together and are the kids truly that loud? Was her husband and college girl trying to sleep next to the fence or something that they could hear the noise? I don't know about other people, but I sleep well enough with brothers running around the house screaming, and that's in the same house. I say you tell ann she's being rude. Or blog, that works too
on Dec 19, 2004

Yippee, acronyms for neighbors.

In honor of you, dear Danny.

I thought Joshua's response to her was rather good

Well, it was classical, off topic Joshua.

And I have to wonder, are your houses so close together and are the kids truly that loud?

Well, we have a nice sized backyard, but their townhouse doesn't have much of one. It is more like a cement patio outlined in grass. My children are no louder than Ann's 80 lb. barking dog. They do battle with pretend laser guns (equipped with kid vocals for the laser sounds) and dramatic deaths do result while the victor cheers! It was in the afternoon, anyway.

 

 

on Dec 20, 2004
Heather, I think you've got every right to power up the lioness in you, especially when someone is at your cubs. People who complain out of hand annoy me. And people who open their mouths without understanding a situation are even more annoying. It is the same as people who move in next to a fun park or primary school and then spend all their time complaining about the noise.

Aren't we lucky we have this site for venting? It is so good to be able to get this stuff off one's chest.

Cheers,

Maso
on Dec 20, 2004

And people who open their mouths without understanding a situation are even more annoying. It is the same as people who move in next to a fun park or primary school and then spend all their time complaining about the noise.

Aren't we lucky we have this site for venting? It is so good to be able to get this stuff off one's chest.

Yes, the college lady that was sick that day, just moved into her townhouse with her significant other. Wonder what she was thinking when she bought the place with a view of our backyard and fort? Ahhhh, sweet silence?

We are lucky to have this site for venting and validation from friends

on Dec 20, 2004
validation from friends


Friend - one of my all time favourite words. Thanks so much for applying to a virtual stranger like me. I feel honoured and flattered.

Cheers,

Maso
on Dec 20, 2004

Thanks so much for applying to a virtual stranger like me

My pleasure and honor.

on Dec 20, 2004
Is Ann just too uptight and grouchy?


- Yes. I do think she was our of line (not to mention insensitive) to address your son that way. And it was just kinda mean.

And yes, good for you, for showing such great restraint. I think your reaction was very appropriate, not over protective at all. It's a shame that they're going to choose to be irritated by the sounds of children playing; it's a very natural, happy noise. I wouldn't let it hinder the kids' fun, though.


on Dec 20, 2004

i'm truly sorry you--and especially your son--have had to suffer because of ann's inability to conduct herself appropriately.  one would hope she'd learned something during the years she's lived.  i know enough about autism to appreciate how cool your son's response was.  you might be able to salvage a positive glimmer out of such a deplorably negative situation by helping your son to see it not as an attack on him personally but a manifestation of a condition this woman has (as do far too many others). unlike him, she may never progess as he is obviously doing.

on Dec 20, 2004

As the mother of a 15 yr old daughter with ADHD who can still get good and loud without realizing it, I can sympathize with you.  People like "Ann," who are unaware or who just don't understand, have to be taken with a grain of salt. I would have been upset with her remarks as well, and would probably have responded in much the same way.

Her not allowing the grandchildren to come over to play with your children was THEIR loss. After all, they had to spend the whole day with someone who probably expects them to be seen and not heard.....

on Dec 20, 2004

Hamster

. I think your reaction was very appropriate, not over protective at all. It's a shame that they're going to choose to be irritated by the sounds of children playing; it's a very natural, happy noise. I wouldn't let it hinder the kids' fun, though

I did try to talk to Joshua about appropriate voice levels in certain situations, but quickly deserted that  converstation. I had no grounds for why his voice level would be inappropriate in our back yard in the middle of the day. Thanks for your comment.

kingbee

i'm truly sorry you--and especially your son--have had to suffer because of ann's inability to conduct herself appropriately. one would hope she'd learned something during the years she's lived.

Thank you, kingbee. Yes, one would hope she would have learned something. I have to admit that I was doubly shocked because she is from England. Aren't they supposed to be so polite and proper?

by helping your son to see it not as an attack on him personally but a manifestation of a condition this woman has (as do far too many others). unlike him, she may never progess as he is obviously doing.

Thank you for this. I will most certainly tell him what you said. I think it is brilliant.

Poetmom99

As the mother of a 15 yr old daughter with ADHD who can still get good and loud without realizing it, I can sympathize with you.
 

Yes I am sure you can understand. Joshua, like your daughter, has no idea how loud he gets.

Her not allowing the grandchildren to come over to play with your children was THEIR loss. After all, they had to spend the whole day with someone who probably expects them to be seen and not heard.....

I had not considered this, but you are probably right. So sad for all the children involved.

on Dec 21, 2004

heather,

I read this piece and shuddered. It's appalling that people have so much intolerance for children, especially those wired a little "different" (I am an adult with ADD, and it's highly probable I deal with Apsberger's, which is very similar, although it's never been definitively diagnosed, so I have some small idea where he comes from).

It reminds me of a time when we were visiting friends when our oldest was a toddler. She was running through the house, shouting, and the question arose: "Have you considered seeing if you can get her on ritalin". It was the last time we visited those individuals at their house.

on Dec 21, 2004

it's highly probable I deal with Apsberger's, which is very similar, although it's never been definitively diagnosed, so I have some small idea where he comes from).

Yes, you do know, Gideon. My son's "highly functioning autism" is Apsberger's. Most people do not know of Apsberger, so I give the definition instead. We do the best we can with Joshua. He is an amazing boy far more brilliant than most people take the time to see or give him credit for. Last year, our school diagnostician tried to convince us he was just retarded according to his IQ score. We would have none of that!

Thank you for your comment and understanding, Gideon.

on Dec 21, 2004
My wife found out in the last few years that her mother has Aspergers Syndrome, which helped my her a great deal in getting over many 'issues' she had with her mother while she was growing up. Her mother lacked any sympathy or empathy and would randomly say things 'off topic', to the point that it would drive my wife to distraction. She is also extremely literal and pedantic. But now that my wife understands that her mother has a problem, she has been able to deal with her feelings for her mother and actually come to love and appreciate her. Having said that, her mother is a wonderful woman, extremely intelligent and quite funny, in her own way. It is always good to know what is going on with someone before making judging them. Too many people think they're qualified to be judge, jury and executioners without knowing the facts.

Cheers,

Maso

2 Pages1 2